Fight to retain X-ray clinic is over
By Rachel Maclean
The Eagle
The only X-ray clinic in Cochrane shut down Feb. 20 because Alberta Health Services (AHS) deemed taking over the service too expensive and it did not want to interfere with a private business consolidating its services into Calgary.
The clinic, EFW Radiology, was located on the second floor of the First Street professional building.
It was a decision, according to Banff-Cochrane Conservative MLA Janis Tarchuk Feb. 23, that is supported by the Minister of Alberta Health and Wellness Ron Liepert, and his letter relaying this announcement to the town is on its way.
“Now we are approaching the limit of what we can do,” said Mayor Truper McBride at the Feb. 23 town council meeting.
He had written an open letter Feb. 13 to Liepert asking for help in retaining the service.
McBride said at a meeting with AHS on Feb. 12 he was told they did not have the “marching orders” or the funds from the province to keep the clinic open.
McBride hoped contacting Liepert would have helped keep the X-ray clinic open.
A spokesman for the health minister said he was out of the country and not available for comment.
Questions about the service were relayed to Alberta Health and Wellness spokesman Howard May, who said while AHS gets funding from the province it is ultimately that body’s decision to help keep the X-ray clinic in Cochrane.
Bruce Conway, spokesman for AHS, said this was a business decision made by a private company and there are a number of alternate diagnostic imaging facilities in Calgary, Airdrie and Canmore.
He said the closest X-ray available to Cochrane residents is in Crowfoot Crossing in Calgary.
“There are plans for diagnostic imaging services in the new urgent care centre scheduled for 2011,” said Conway. “Of course with all capital projects, this kind of development does hinge on available provincial dollars.”
He said Cochrane is not alone as “there are a number of communities that are wondering what their future will be in terms of a number of services.”
Chris Histed, chief operating officer for EFW Radiology, said the company met with AHS to see if it would take over the service until the urgent care centre opened.
“We did have some discussions of potentially bridging the service,” said Histed. “But I am not sure what went on after that.”
McBride said it is probably fair to say that Cochrane has got the “short-end of the stick” when it comes to health care compared to communities like Okotoks, Canmore and Airdrie.
On Feb. 20, McBride met with provincial Liberal leader Dr. David Swann who had asked to discuss the problem with him and his Liberal caucus. McBride said the Liberals repeatedly raised the issue in the legislature while during the week of Feb. 16-20.
“At least we are speaking to someone in the province that is listening,” said McBride. “We do understand this would be out of the norm for the province when a private company steps away to step in and run it, but what we are saying is that Cochrane is growing, and growing rapidly, and it is unacceptable for us to see a reduction in health care services.”
McBride said the next move is to meet with Alberta Transport Minister Luke Ouellette and Tarchuk.
Tarchuk said she is very disappointed to hear Cochrane is losing its X-ray services. She said it is too bad AHS couldn’t keep it open until the new urgent care centre is completed, but she sees how it is not financially feasible.
“I think what is important now is to monitor the transition period,” she said.

